Roofing/Metal vs. shingles
Short answer: Ten homeowners posted both a metal and a shingle quote for the same house in 2026. Exposed-fastener metal was quoted at 0.9 to 1.5 times the shingle price, and in three of five cases at about the same price. Standing seam was quoted at 1.6 to 2.7 times the shingle price, about double on average. None came near the four-to-one gap some guides publish.

What did homeowners get quoted for metal and shingles on the same house?

Metal roof vs. shingles cost is easiest to judge when one house gets both quotes. The answer depends on which metal: screw-down panels with exposed fasteners, or standing seam with hidden ones.

Exposed-fastener metal vs. shingles

WhereShingle quoteExposed-fastener quoteMetal vs. shingle
Not stated (thread)$24,000–$33,000$21,000–$30,0000.9x
New Mexico (thread)—"roughly the same price"1.0x
Not stated (thread)$27,000$28,0001.0x
Northeast Ohio, contractor C (thread)$20,000$26,0001.3x
Northeast Ohio, contractor A (same thread)$17,900$26,2001.5x

Standing seam vs. shingles

WhereShingle quoteStanding seam quoteMetal vs. shingle
Not stated (thread)—"about 60 percent more"1.6x
Not stated (thread)$27,000$52,0001.9x
Northeast Ohio, contractor A (thread)$17,900$35,500 (26 gauge)2.0x
Northeast Ohio, contractor C$20,000$44,000 (26 gauge)2.2x
Northeast Ohio, contractor B$23,400$62,300 (26 gauge)2.7x

Each row compares quotes for one house in one round of bidding; the Ohio rows compare each contractor's own entry-level shingle with its own metal price. Contractor B also quoted 24-gauge standing seam at $82,000, which is 3.5 times its shingle price.

The Ohio thread is the cleanest test, because three contractors priced all options for one roof. Their standing seam quotes for the same house ran from $35,500 to $62,300. The spread between roofers was larger than the gap between materials.

Pairs where the type of metal was not stated

Four more homeowners posted both quotes without naming the panel. Metal came in at 0.8 times shingles in rural Pennsylvania ($14,600 against $18,000, with no tear-off in the metal quote), 1.5 times in one case ($56,176 against $37,447), 1.9 times in the Pacific Northwest ($50,000 against $27,000) and 2.0 to 2.5 times near Philadelphia ($24,500–$52,000 against $12,000–$21,000). Links are in the sources.

One homeowner saw the order reversed. Two companies quoted $32,000 to $35,000 for shingles on a 15-square roof and $50,000 for stone-coated metal. A third then quoted $18,500 for snap-lock standing seam with new decking.

Why do guides say metal costs four times more?

This Old House puts asphalt shingles at about $7 per square foot and metal at $28, or $14,000 against $56,000 on a 2,000-square-foot roof. Those figures come from a cost model, not from quotes, and the posted quotes sit well below that ratio.

Metal quote with a stated roof sizeRoofQuotePer square
Snap-lock standing seam with new decking (thread)15 sq$18,500$1,233
Standing seam, 26 gauge, Minnesota (thread)22 sq$30,000–$40,000$1,364–$1,818
Metal shingles plus 2 squares of bitumen (thread)13 sq$22,300$1,715
Exposed fastener on a steep roof, several old layers removed (thread)12 sq$30,000$2,500
Standing seam on a detached garage, New Jersey, no tear-off (thread)5 sq$12,875$2,575
Standing seam, two-layer tear-off, full re-deck and gutters, Southern California (thread)24 sq$95,000$3,958

The median asphalt quote in our dataset was $727 per square. The two standing seam quotes on ordinary roofs without heavy extras, at $1,233 to $1,818 per square, are 1.7 to 2.5 times that. The higher per-square figures belong to a very small roof, a steep roof with layers to strip, and a job with a full re-deck.

When is the metal premium worth paying?

The quotes cannot answer that, but they frame it. If standing seam costs twice what shingles cost, it has to save you a second shingle roof while you still own the house.

This Old House gives shingles 15 to 50 years and metal up to 100. The homeowner who was offered standing seam at 60% more planned to stay at least 15 years. On those lifespans a 15-year stay does not recover the premium on durability alone; a 40-year stay might.

Exposed-fastener metal is a different decision. At about the shingle price, the question is upkeep more than cost. One roofer told a homeowner that well-installed shingles outlast the screws on an exposed-fastener roof (thread). Ask every metal bidder which panel, which gauge, and whether the old roof comes off. Two homeowners here were quoted metal laid over the existing shingles, which removes a line item and hides the deck.

Practical check: put both quotes on the same footing before comparing. Same tear-off, same decking allowance, same roof area. Then use the quote checker on the shingle number to see whether the baseline itself is fair.

Related: Is $30,000 too much for a roof?

Metal roof vs. shingles cost FAQ

Is a metal roof more expensive than shingles?

It depends on the type. In same-house quotes posted in 2026, exposed-fastener metal was quoted at 0.9 to 1.5 times the shingle price, and standing seam at 1.6 to 2.7 times, about double on average.

How much does a standing seam metal roof cost per square?

Posted standing seam quotes on ordinary roofs without heavy extras ran $1,233 to $1,818 per square. Small roofs and jobs with a full re-deck ran $2,575 to $3,958. The median asphalt quote in the same dataset was $727 per square.

Why was my metal quote cheaper than shingles?

Check the panel type and the scope. The metal quotes that matched or undercut shingles used exposed-fastener panels, or were priced to go over the old shingles without a tear-off.

Is standing seam worth twice the price of shingles?

It depends on how long you stay. This Old House gives shingles 15 to 50 years and metal up to 100, so the premium pays back on lifespan only if you would otherwise replace shingles while you own the house.

Sources

  1. This Old House, "Shingles vs. Metal Roof Cost (2026 Guide)", updated Oct 2, 2026. thisoldhouse.com/roofing/shingles-vs-metal-roof-cost
  2. Reddit threads, Jan – Nov 2026, linked in the tables. Pairs without a stated metal type: rural Pennsylvania, $56,176 vs. $37,447, Pacific Northwest, Philadelphia area.
  3. HomeCostBench, Roof Replacement Cost 2026, dataset of 44 homeowner quotes (CSV).

AI assistance was used in researching and drafting this article; every figure was checked against the linked source. No affiliate links. Quotes come from public homeowner posts and reflect what was quoted, not what was paid. Method: how a benchmark is built.