Site/Methodology

1. Where the quotes come from

We collect quotes that homeowners post publicly, mainly in home-improvement communities on Reddit, within a fixed time window (normally the previous twelve months). A quote is included when the original post states a dollar amount and describes the work. Replies are not used as data, because they are usually opinions about a quote rather than quotes themselves. Each row links to the thread it came from.

2. What is excluded

Quotes outside the United States, amounts that appear only in an image, ranges with no project size, and posts where the scope cannot be identified. Exclusions are listed on each benchmark page.

3. Scope coding

Prices are only comparable within a scope. For insulation we use three codes: A (top-up over existing material), B (remove and replace), C (full restoration: removal plus air sealing and/or pest cleanup). Other project types get their own scope codes, defined on the page. When a quote bundles unrelated work, it is kept and labeled rather than dropped.

4. Normalization

Where the homeowner states a size, we compute cost per unit (square foot for insulation and roofing, tonnage for HVAC). When a range is given, the midpoint is used and marked. Medians are reported with the sample size. We do not report averages for samples under ten.

5. Comparison with published guides

Figures from cost guides are copied as printed on the day of collection, with each page's own last-updated date. Guides older than two years are included for comparison and labeled as older. We do not adjust guide figures for inflation.

6. Verification levels

Every number on a page carries one of these labels internally: verified (one authoritative source), cross-verified (two independent sources), single-source (one community report), or derived (computed from verified inputs). Headline claims must be cross-verified. Anything we could not verify is listed under "excluded" on the page rather than used.

7. Limitations we always state

Posted quotes skew toward surprising ones, because people rarely ask the internet about a quote that looked fine. Samples are small. Region is often unknown. Savings figures come from government models, not from measured bills. These limits are printed on every page, next to the data they apply to.

Corrections and updates

Datasets are refreshed when enough new quotes accumulate, or at least annually. If you find an error or a quote we misread, use the contact details on the about page; corrections are noted on the page with a date.

Tools and transparency

Research, data processing and drafting use AI assistance. Every figure is checked by a person against the linked source before publication. This site carries no affiliate links and accepts no payment from contractors, manufacturers or cost-guide publishers.