Roofing/Roof replacement cost
Cost benchmark· ● Published November 19, 2026· 44 homeowner quotes · 6 cost guides· Download the dataset (CSV)
House roof half covered in new dark asphalt shingles, half stripped to plywood decking
Illustration. Figures in this article come from the linked sources, never from images.
The headline number
$727median asphalt quote per roofing square, Nov 2025 – Nov 2026 (n = 23)

Roof replacement cost in 2026 depends on who you ask. Angi puts the national average at $9,611. GAF, citing Verisk, puts it at $17,631. The 44 quotes homeowners posted for a second opinion ran from $7,100 to $65,000, with a median of $22,900. Priced per square (100 sq ft of roof), a standard asphalt shingle replacement clustered between $580 and $800.

Key takeaways

  • A standard asphalt shingle replacement was quoted at a median of $714 per square. Thirteen of 18 such quotes were at or under $800 per square.
  • That is $7.14 per square foot: inside Angi's $4 to $11 range, but above RoofingCalculator ($3.50 to $6.00) and Homewyse ($5.09 to $6.66).
  • Full re-decking or three or more layers to tear off pushed quotes to $1,250 to $2,545 per square.
  • Four roofers quoted the same 44-square Connecticut roof at $26,000, $32,000, $33,000 and $58,000. One number is not a market price.
  • Check your own quote per square with the checker below, then compare the scope before you compare the price.

What do the cost guides say a roof replacement costs?

Six widely cited sources put the average roof replacement between $9,500 and $29,909, and the price per square foot between $3.50 and $11. The spread comes from what each source counts: roof size, material mix, and whether the data is contractor jobs, insurance claims or a survey.

SourceHeadline figurePer sq ftBased onDated
Angi$9,611 average; most pay $5,903–$13,380$4–$1132,999 projects from Angi prosOct 22, 2026
NerdWallet$9,500 average; $5,800–$46,000$4–$11Cites AngiSep 16, 2025
GAF$17,631 average (2025)—Verisk 2025 U.S. Roof Reportundated
This Old House$29,909 for 2,000 sq ft, all materials; $10,319 asphaltabout $5.16 asphaltSurvey of 1,000 homeownersOct 7, 2026
Homewyse—$5.09–$6.66 asphaltCost model, basic installMay 2026
RoofingCalculator$6,000–$9,000 for a 1,700 sq ft asphalt roof$3.50–$6.00 asphaltCost modelundated

Figures copied as printed on each page on November 19, 2026. The This Old House per-square-foot figure is its $10,319 asphalt total divided by 2,000 sq ft.

None of these numbers is wrong for what it measures. But a homeowner holding a $24,000 quote cannot tell from a $9,611 average whether the roofer is high or the average is about a smaller roof. The quotes below are priced the way roofers price: per square.

What were homeowners actually quoted in the last 12 months?

We collected US roof replacement quotes that homeowners posted with a dollar amount between November 2025 and November 2026. That gave 44 quotes from 35 threads: 23 asphalt quotes with a stated roof size, 3 metal or composite quotes with a size, and 18 with a total only.

Three roofing estimate sheets side by side on a desk with shingle samples, a tape measure and a calculator
Illustration. Every quote in the table links to the thread it came from.
PostedWhereRoofScopeQuote$/square
Aug 2026Texas Gulf Coast37 sqOwens Corning shingles and membrane, all vents, 3 deck panels included, windstorm compliance (thread)$13,500$365
Nov 2026Phoenix, AZ28 sqTear-off of 2 layers, GAF shingles, up to 10 sheets of decking included (thread)$15,000$536
Nov 2026not stated (very high cost of living)30 sqGAF HDZ or Tamko Titan XT, 5 sheets of plywood included, 15-year workmanship warranty (thread)$17,500$583
Aug 2026Hartford County, CT44 sqFull replacement of 25-year-old roof (thread)$26,000$591
Sep 2026not stated (high cost of living)12 sqTownhome roof replacement; Landmark Pro upgrade +10% (thread)$7,100$592
Oct 2026not stated (high cost of living)12 sqTownhome roof replacement (thread)$7,200$600
Aug 2026Pierce County, WA20 sqGAF Timberline HDZ (thread)$12,000$600
Nov 2026Phoenix, AZ28 sqTear-off of 2 layers, GAF shingles, up to 5 sheets of decking, new drip edge (thread)$17,000$607
Sep 2026not stated (high cost of living)12 sqEnd-unit townhome roof replacement (thread)$8,000$667
Nov 2026not stated (very high cost of living)30 sqGAF HDZ, small contractor with subs, 3-year workmanship warranty (thread)$21,000$700
Nov 2026not stated30 sqNot itemized; estimates around $700 per square installed (thread)$21,000$700
Aug 2026Hartford County, CT44 sqFull replacement of 25-year-old roof (thread)$32,000$727
Aug 2026Pierce County, WA20 sqGAF Timberline UHDZ (thread)$15,000$750
Aug 2026Hartford County, CT44 sqFull replacement of 25-year-old roof (thread)$33,000$750
Nov 2026not stated (very high cost of living)30 sqGAF HDZ, ice shield, synthetic underlayment, 8 sheets of plywood included (thread)$23,800$793
Oct 2026Orange County, CA32.5 sqGAF Timberline shingles, single-story home (thread)$29,500$908
May 2026not stated30 sqMid-range shingle on a 3,000 sq ft roof (thread)$35,000$1,167
Dec 2025Midwest14 sqGAF asphalt shingles on an A-frame home (thread)$16,500$1,179
Nov 2026Chicago, IL24 sqTear-off of 5 layers (4 asphalt + cedar shake), full new decking (thread)$30,000$1,250
Aug 2026Hartford County, CT44 sqFull replacement of 25-year-old roof (thread)$58,000$1,318
Feb 2026not stated30 sq1-layer tear-off, ice shield at perimeter, new drip edge, architectural shingles, 3 skylights (thread)$44,000$1,467
May 2026Massachusetts14 sqTear-off of slate, full re-deck (48 sheets), CertainTeed Landmark (thread)$22,000$1,571
Feb 2026Chicago suburbs, IL11 sq30-year shingles, 3/12 pitch, all plywood replaced (thread)$28,000$2,545

Asphalt shingle quotes with a stated roof size, sorted by price per square. One square is 100 sq ft of roof surface. Totals-only and metal quotes are in the CSV.

The 18 totals-only quotes had a median of $25,250 and ran from $9,500 to $65,000. They are left out of the per-square math because a house's floor area is not its roof area: a 1,600 sq ft Texas house in this dataset carried 37 squares of roof.

Roof replacement cost per square by scope

Grouped by what the roofer was asked to do, a standard asphalt replacement was quoted at $365 to $1,467 per square with a median of $714. Jobs with full re-decking or many layers to remove were quoted at $1,250 to $2,545 per square.

Asphalt shingle quotes, $ per roofing square

Each dot is one posted quote (Nov 2025 – Nov 2026). The grey bar is Angi's published $4 to $11 per square foot, shown per square.

$0 $400 $800 $1,200 $1,600 $2,000 $2,400 quoted price per roofing square (100 sq ft) Standardn = 18 Two-layer tear-offn = 2 Heavy scopen = 3 posted quoteAngi $4–$11 per sq ftmedian
ScopeWhat it includesQuotesRange per squareMedian
A · Standard replacementOne-layer tear-off, underlayment, architectural shingles, a few sheets of decking18$365–$1,467$714
B · Two-layer tear-offSame, with two layers of old shingles to remove2$536–$607$572
C · Heavy scopeFull re-deck, or three or more layers including cedar or slate3$1,250–$2,545$1,571

Source: dataset rows above. Small samples: treat the bands as orientation, not as a price list. Both two-layer quotes are for one Phoenix roof.

Two findings matter more than the medians. First, the cluster: 13 of the 18 standard quotes sat at or under $800 per square, across Texas, Washington, Connecticut and two high-cost metros. Second, the tail: the five standard quotes above $900 per square came with no extra scope the homeowner could name, except three skylights in one case and a steep A-frame in another.

Why do quotes for the same roof differ so much?

Five homeowners in the dataset posted several quotes for one roof. Four of them saw a spread of 13% to 36% between the lowest and highest. The fifth, in Connecticut, saw the highest quote come in at 2.2 times the lowest.

RoofQuotesLowestHighestSpread
Hartford County, CT · 44 squares (thread)4$26,000$58,0002.2x
High-cost metro · 30 squares (thread)3$17,500$23,8001.36x
Pierce County, WA · 20 squares, two shingle lines (thread)2$12,000$15,0001.25x
Phoenix, AZ · 28 squares (thread)2$15,000$17,0001.13x
Townhome · 12 squares (thread)3$7,100$8,0001.13x

The totals-only threads show the same pattern with wider gaps. A Southwest Ohio homeowner got $11,000, $16,000 and $23,000 for one tear-off. A New Jersey family was quoted $42,000 for a full replacement with all new decking; three later roofers quoted $12,000 to $16,000 and all three said the roof did not need replacing yet.

"We were absolutely getting hosed by that first company and they unfortunately tried to take advantage of us in a vulnerable situation."Homeowner, New Jersey, March 2026 — r/Roofing

Some opening prices are not prices at all. One homeowner watched a $37,447 bid drop to $22,500 in the same sitting, good for one week. Another was quoted $35,000 by a national company that had opened at $50,000.

Practical check: three quotes is the minimum. In the two threads where homeowners reported going back for more, the price fell from $14,000 to about $11,500 and from $42,000 to $12,000–$16,000.

What pushes a roof quote above $800 per square?

Three things did most of the work in the posted quotes: replacing the roof deck, tearing off extra layers, and switching material. Each one can be read off the quote before you sign.

Line itemPublished costSeen in posted quotes
Roof deckingAngi: $2,600–$9,000 for a full re-deck, $2–$6 per sq ftQuotes that stated an allowance included 3 to 10 sheets. Extra sheets were priced at $50, $70 and $80–$91 each. The three heavy-scope quotes all came in at $1,250 per square or more.
Tear-off and extra layersRoofingCalculator: $0.40–$2.00 per sq ftTwo layers in Phoenix still came in at $536–$607 per square. Five layers in Chicago: $1,250. One quote charged $25 per square per extra layer.
Material upgradeAngi: asphalt $5,800–$20,000 installedUpgrading one shingle line added 25% on the same roof ($12,000 to $15,000). Metal and composite quotes ran $1,715 to $2,500 per square.
Skylights, steep pitchNot priced separately in most guidesThe two highest standard quotes with a named reason: three skylights ($1,467 per square) and a steep A-frame ($1,179).

Decking is the item to pin down in writing. A roofer cannot see the deck until the shingles are off, so the quote should state how many sheets are included and the price per extra sheet. In the Texas quote that was three panels and $70 each, which caps the surprise.

Is my roof replacement quote reasonable? Check it per square

Enter your roof size in squares, the scope and the quoted price. The checker converts it to dollars per square and places it against the posted quotes for that scope. It runs in your browser; nothing is sent anywhere.

Quote checker

Where does your quote land?

Your quote
$720 /square

—

Posted quotes for this scope
$365 – $1,467

Median $714 across 18 quotes.

Your quote lists squares on the first page or in the measurement report. If it only gives square feet of roof, divide by 100. Benchmarks come from the asphalt quotes in the table above. Small samples; use as orientation.

Methodology

Quote dataset. Searched Reddit on November 19, 2026 for roof replacement quote threads posted in the previous twelve months (r/Roofing, r/homeowners, r/HomeMaintenance, r/AskContractors and local subreddits). Kept US threads where the original post stated a dollar amount for a full replacement. Excluded Canadian, UK, Irish and Australian threads, repairs, image-only amounts and contractor-side pricing discussions. Price per square uses the roof size as stated by the homeowner; where a range was given, the midpoint is used and marked. Quotes that gave only the house's floor area are kept as totals and are not converted. Scope was coded from the homeowner's description. Replies were not collected, so the dataset reflects what homeowners were quoted, not what they paid. Download: CSV, 44 rows.

Published guides. Figures were copied as printed from Angi, NerdWallet, GAF, This Old House, Homewyse and RoofingCalculator on November 19, 2026, with each page's own date.

Limitations. Twenty-three sized asphalt quotes from 14 homeowners is a small sample, and several homeowners contribute more than one quote. Region is unknown for about a third of the rows. People who post quotes online are more likely to have received a surprising one, which pushes the sample upward compared with all jobs. Pitch and story count are rarely stated.

Update schedule. Dataset refreshed when new threads add at least ten sized quotes, or annually. Corrections: see the about page. More on the method: how a benchmark is built. Related benchmark: attic insulation cost.

AI assistance was used in researching and drafting this article; every figure was checked against the linked source. This page contains no affiliate links. HomeCostBench does not sell roofing and is not affiliated with any contractor, manufacturer or cost-guide publisher.

Roof replacement cost FAQ

How much does a roof replacement cost in 2026?

Published averages run from $9,611 (Angi) to $17,631 (GAF, citing Verisk). Homeowner quotes posted in the past 12 months had a median of $22,900. For asphalt shingles, the median was $727 per roofing square, or $21,000 for the roofs with a stated size.

What is a fair price per square for a new roof?

In posted quotes, a standard asphalt shingle replacement had a median of $714 per square, and 13 of 18 quotes were at or under $800. Full re-decking or three or more layers to remove ran $1,250 to $2,545 per square.

Is $30,000 too much for a roof?

It depends on the size. $30,000 is about $750 per square on a 40-square roof, which is typical. On a 20-square roof it is $1,500 per square, which only the heavy-scope quotes reached.

How many roofing quotes should I get?

At least three. Four roofers quoted one 44-square Connecticut roof between $26,000 and $58,000, and a New Jersey family went from a $42,000 quote to $12,000–$16,000 with three more.

How much does roof decking add?

Posted quotes that stated an allowance included 3 to 10 sheets and priced extra sheets at $50 to $91 each. Angi puts a full re-deck at $2,600 to $9,000. Ask for the included sheet count and the per-sheet price in writing.

How do I find my roof size in squares?

One square is 100 sq ft of roof surface. Most quotes state the squares or include a measurement report. Roof area is larger than floor area: one 1,600 sq ft house in the dataset had 37 squares of roof.

Sources

  1. Angi, "How Much Does Roof Replacement Cost? [2026]", updated Oct 22, 2026. angi.com/articles/how-much-does-roof-replacement-cost.htm
  2. Angi, "How Much Does Roof Decking Cost to Replace? [2026 Data]", updated Oct 22, 2026.
  3. NerdWallet, "Roof Replacement Cost in 2026", updated Sep 16, 2025.
  4. GAF, "Roof Replacement Costs", citing Verisk, 2025 U.S. Roof Report. gaf.com/en-us/plan-design/homeowner-education/roof-cost
  5. This Old House, "New Roof Cost Guide (2026)", updated Oct 7, 2026.
  6. Homewyse, "Cost to Install Asphalt Shingle Roof", May 2026.
  7. RoofingCalculator, "Roof Replacement Cost by Location, Roof Type & Material". roofingcalculator.com
  8. Reddit threads, Nov 2025 – Nov 2026, linked individually in the quote table and dataset.