Garage Door Spring Replacement Cost: What Homeowners Were Charged
What does garage door spring replacement cost in real quotes?
Garage door spring replacement cost was posted by eight homeowners between February and October 2026. All nine prices were above the $250 that Angi gives as the national average.
| Where | Price | Work |
|---|---|---|
| Not stated (thread) | $395 paid | Both springs, parts and labor |
| Ohio (thread) | $450 | One new spring on a two-car door, second company |
| St. Louis, MO (thread) | $470 paid | Broken spring; the estimate was $520 |
| Bucks County, PA (thread) | $899 | Two extension springs, four cables and an opener belt |
| Connecticut (thread) | about $1,000 paid | Spring, drums and cables |
| Phoenix area (thread) | $1,095 | Full torsion system; out of pocket after a home warranty paid $300 |
| Not stated (thread) | $1,100 | Four springs for a wood-faced door of more than 500 pounds |
| Ohio, same door as row 2 | $2,000 | New spring and bearings, first company |
| Not stated (thread) | $3,000 | New springs, proposed during a cable repair |
Nine prices is a small sample; use it as orientation. Three were paid, six were quotes.
The middle half of the nine ran from $470 to $1,100. Angi says most homeowners pay $150 to $350 and that costs can reach $500. Six of the nine posted prices were above $500.
Why were some spring quotes above $1,000?
Mostly because the quote covered more than springs. The three lowest prices, $395 to $470, were for springs alone. Four of the six higher ones added cables, drums, bearings, a belt or a full torsion system.
- Springs alone, standard door: $395 for both springs, $450 for one, and $470 for a broken spring in St. Louis.
- Springs plus parts: $899 with four cables and an opener belt, about $1,000 with drums and cables, $1,095 for a full torsion system.
- Heavy door: $1,100 for four springs. The company said the springs fitted four years earlier were the wrong weight class for the door.
- The two highest: $2,000 for a spring and bearings, and $3,000 for new springs.
Whether the extra parts are needed is the question to ask. The Bucks County homeowner had two companies look at the same door. One proposed replacing one spring. The other proposed two springs, four cables and the belt for $899.
The Connecticut homeowner estimated the parts at about $150 and the work at an hour to an hour and a half. Angi puts labor for a residential spring replacement at $75 to $150.
Is it worth getting a second quote for a broken spring?
In the one case with two companies and two prices, yes. An Ohio homeowner was quoted $2,000 by the first company and $450 by the second for a new spring on the same door.
The first company said the spring was the wrong size and quoted $2,000 for a spring and bearings, plus $1,000 for a new opener. The second company balanced the existing springs instead, for $230 with a twelve-month guarantee.
- Ask for the price of springs alone. Then ask what each added part costs and why it is needed.
- Push back on the estimate. The St. Louis homeowner's estimate dropped from $520 to $470 after one conversation. Ten years earlier, both springs on the same door had cost $200.
- Check a home warranty. In the Phoenix case the warranty company paid $300 toward the repair.
A broken spring sometimes leads to a quote for a whole new door. One Salt Lake City homeowner got a bid of over $7,300 for a new door after a spring broke. See the garage door replacement cost benchmark for what doors were quoted at, and check a spring price with the quote checker.
Related: garage door opener installation cost · double garage door cost
Garage door spring replacement cost FAQ
How much does garage door spring replacement cost?
Nine posted prices ran from $395 to $3,000, with a median of $1,000. The three lowest, all for springs alone, were $395 to $470. Angi reports a national average of $250.
Is $1,000 too much for garage door spring replacement?
It is the median of nine posted prices, but the quotes at that level included more than springs: drums and cables, or a full torsion system. Spring-only jobs were $395 to $470.
How much does it cost to replace both garage door springs?
One homeowner paid $395 for both springs, parts and labor. Another was quoted $899 for two extension springs, four cables and an opener belt.
Should I get a second quote for a broken garage door spring?
In one posted case an Ohio homeowner was quoted $2,000 for a spring and bearings. A second company quoted $450 for a new spring and balanced the existing ones for $230.
Sources
- Angi, How Much Does Garage Door Spring Replacement Cost?, updated Oct 30, 2026. Figures as printed on November 19, 2026.
- Reddit threads, Feb – Oct 2026, linked in the text.
- HomeCostBench, Garage Door Replacement Cost 2026, dataset of 44 homeowner prices (CSV).
AI assistance was used in researching and drafting this article; every figure was checked against the linked source. No affiliate links. Quotes come from public homeowner posts and reflect what was quoted, not what was paid. Method: how a benchmark is built.