50-Gallon Water Heater Cost Installed: What Homeowners Were Quoted
What does a 50-gallon water heater cost installed?
50-gallon water heater cost installed was posted by twelve homeowners between December 2025 and November 2026. Seventeen of the 21 prices were for gas tanks.
| Where | Tank | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| St. Louis, MO (thread) | Gas | $2,150, $2,536, $3,071 | Three companies; haul-away and expansion tank included; the lowest was chosen |
| Montgomery County, MD (thread) | Electric | $2,150 paid | Drip pan, haul-away, one-year labor warranty |
| Southeast Pennsylvania (thread) | Gas | $2,176 to $4,777 | Seven quotes from five companies; the top three differ by warranty |
| Not stated (thread) | Bradford White | about $2,200 | The same plumber priced a 65-gallon tank at closer to $3,500 |
| Not stated (thread) | Gas, attic space | $2,200 paid; $3,800 quoted | Local plumber against a large company |
| Small rural town (thread) | Gas, A. O. Smith | $2,500 paid | Haul-away, new pipes and valves |
| Not stated (thread) | Gas, Bradford White, attic | $2,798 | Automatic shut-off valve, drain pan, sediment trap |
| Central North Carolina (thread) | Electric low-boy, crawlspace | $2,800 | Lowest of three quotes |
| Bay Area, CA (thread) | Gas, Bradford White | $3,275 | Expansion tank, drain pan, disposal; in a garage |
| Denver, CO (thread) | Gas, Bradford White | $4,600 | No extras stated |
| Charlotte, NC (thread) | Gas, attic | $4,800 | Includes a pressure reducing valve; $1,000 attributed to the attic |
| Northern Virginia (thread) | State | $4,800 | Expansion tank brought up to code |
Standard atmospheric or electric tanks. Prices are quotes unless marked paid. One homeowner supplied seven of the 21 prices; counting each homeowner once, the median is $2,900.
A. O. Smith, which makes many of these tanks, publishes $600 to $1,650 for a complete 50-gallon replacement. Angi gives $600 to $2,500 for any tank. Fourteen of the 21 posted prices were above $2,500.
Is a 50-gallon gas water heater more expensive than electric?
The posted prices cannot settle it. The 17 gas prices had a median of $3,071. Only two prices were for electric tanks, $2,150 and $2,800.
A gas tank needs a vent and a gas connection, which is more to check and replace. Two posted electric prices are too few to put a number on the difference.
What does a 50-gallon power-vent water heater cost?
About twice as much in the posted quotes. Four quotes for 50-gallon power-vent or direct-vent tanks ran from $3,900 to $7,100.
- Charlotte, NC: around $6,000 from a large company and about $3,900 from the gas utility for a direct-vent tank.
- Mid-Atlantic: $5,100 and $7,100 from two local companies for a 60,000 BTU power-vent tank.
If your current tank has a fan on top and a plastic vent pipe, it is a power-vent model, and the standard-tank prices above do not apply.
Should I get a 40, 50 or larger tank?
On price alone, 40 and 50 gallons were quoted about the same. Going larger cost more.
- 40 gallons: 17 posted prices, median $3,200.
- 50 gallons: 21 posted prices, median $2,800.
- 65 to 75 gallons: four posted prices from $3,500 to $5,500.
One homeowner was quoted $4,030 for two 50-gallon gas tanks installed with flue piping and an expansion tank, or $2,015 each.
More: water heater replacement cost benchmark · Is $3,000 too much for a water heater?
50-gallon water heater cost FAQ
How much does a 50-gallon water heater cost installed?
Twenty-one posted prices for a standard 50-gallon tank ran from $2,150 to $4,800, with a median of $2,800. A. O. Smith publishes $600 to $1,650 for a complete 50-gallon replacement.
How much does a 50-gallon gas water heater cost installed?
Seventeen posted prices for a standard 50-gallon gas tank ran from $2,150 to $4,800, with a median of $3,071.
How much does a 50-gallon power-vent water heater cost installed?
Four posted quotes for 50-gallon power-vent or direct-vent gas tanks ran from $3,900 to $7,100.
Is a 50-gallon water heater more expensive than a 40-gallon one?
Not in the posted prices. The median was $2,800 for 50 gallons and $3,200 for 40 gallons. Tanks of 65 to 75 gallons were quoted $3,500 to $5,500.
Sources
- Angi, How Much Does Water Heater Replacement Cost?, updated Oct 16, 2026; The Home Depot, Cost to Replace a Water Heater; A. O. Smith, How Much Does a Water Heater Cost to Replace?. Figures as printed on November 19, 2026.
- Reddit threads, Dec 2025 – Nov 2026, linked in the table.
- HomeCostBench, Water Heater Replacement Cost 2026, dataset of 66 homeowner prices (CSV).
AI assistance was used in researching and drafting this article; every figure was checked against the linked source. No affiliate links. Quotes come from public homeowner posts and reflect what was quoted, not what was paid. Method: how a benchmark is built.